EC Details Proposed Renewable Energy Directive
January 28, 2008 // Published as a news service by IHS
The European Commission (EC) proposed a renewable energydirective as part of a comprehensive energy and climate change package proposed on Jan. 23.
The new directive aims to establish national renewable energy targetsthat result in an overall binding target of a 20% share of renewable energysources in energy consumption in 2020 within the European Union (EU), and a binding 10% minimum target for biofuels in transport to be achieved by each member state.
Three sectors are implicated by renewable energy: electricity, heating andcooling, and transport. It is up to each member state to decide on the mix ofcontributions from these sectors to reach its national target, choosing themeans that best suits its national circumstances.
Member states will also be given the option of achieving their targets by supporting the development of renewable energy in other member states and third countries.
The minimum 10% share of biofuels in transport is applicable in all member states. Biofuels tackle the oil dependence of the transport sector, which the EC believes is oneof the most serious issues affecting security of energy supply that the EUfaces.
The directive also aims to remove unnecessary barriers to the growthof renewable energy - for example, by simplifying the administrative proceduresfor new renewable energy developments. In addition, the directive encourages the development ofbetter types of renewable energy, such as by setting sustainability standards forbiofuels.
Target renewables calculation
The EC contends that if the overall 20% target for renewables is to be reached in an effective manner, individual targets for each member state have to be determined as fairly as possible. Therefore, the EC put forward a simple five-step approach:
- The share of renewable energy in 2005 (the base year for all calculations in the package) is modulated to reflect national starting points and efforts already made for member states that achieved an increase of above 2% between 2001 and 2005.
- 5.5% is added to the modulated 2005 share of renewable energy for every member state.
- This remaining effort (0.16 tonnes of oil equivalent for each person in the EU) is weighted by a GDP/capita index to reflect different levels of wealth across member states, then multiplied by each member state's population.
- These two elements are added together to derive the full renewable energy share of total final energy consumption in 2020.
- Lastly, an overall cap on the target share for renewable energy in 2020 is applied for individual member states.
The EC believes this method of setting the targets provides for a fair distribution of effort across member states.
At the same time, the creation of a tradable guarantee of origin regime allows member states to reach their targets in the most cost-effective manner possible: instead of developing local renewable energy sources, member states will be able to buy guarantees of origin (certificates proving the renewable origin of energy) from other member states where the development of renewable energy is cheaper to produce.
Biofuels
The 10% biofuels target for renewable energy in transport has been set at the same level for each member state in order to ensure consistency in transport fuel specifications and availability. Member states that do not have the relevant resources to produce biofuels will easily be able to obtain renewable transport fuels from elsewhere.
While it would technically be possible for the EU to meet its biofuel needs solely from domestic production, it is both likely and desirable that these needs will, in fact, be met through a combination of domestic EU production and imports from third countries.
Concerns have been raised about whether biofuel production is sustainable. While biofuels are a crucial part of renewable energy policy and a key solution to growing greenhouse gas emissions in the transport sector, they must not be promoted unless they are produced sustainably. Although the majority of biofuels currently consumed in the EU are produced in a sustainable manner, the concerns are legitimate and need to be addressed.
Therefore, the directive sets out stringent environmental sustainability criteria to ensure that biofuels that are to count towards the European targets are sustainable and that they are not in conflict with overall environmental goals.
This means that they must achieve at least a minimum level of greenhouse gas savings and respect a number of requirements related to biodiversity. Among other things, this should prevent the use of land with high biodiversity value, such as natural forests and protected areas, from being used for the production of raw materials for biofuels.
According to the EC, since biofuels cost more than other forms of renewable energy, without a separate minimum target for biofuels, they will not be developed. This matters because greenhouse gas trends are worst in transport, and biofuels are one of the few measures - alongside vehicle fuel economy - realistically capable of making a significant impact on greenhouse gas emissions from transport. In addition, the transport sector's oil dependence is the most serious security of supply problem.
Finally, the EC maintains that Europe must send the right signals for the future and points out that the old cars of 2020 are being built today. Vehicle manufacturers need to know what fuel to design for.
Advantages of renewable energy
The numerous benefits of renewable energy - in terms of the impact on climate change, security of energy supply and long-term economic benefits - are widely accepted. The EC's analysis shows that achieving renewable energy targets will mean the following:
- Savings of 600 to 900 million tonnes of CO2 emissions per year, thereby holding back the rate of climate change and sending a signal to other countries to do the same.
- Reductions in fossil fuel consumption of 200 to 300 million tonnes per year, most of it imported, thereby making energy supplies more certain for European citizens.
- A boost for high-tech industries, providing new economic opportunities and jobs.
All this will cost approximately €13 to €18 billion per year. However, this investment will drive down the price of renewable energy technologies, which will form a growing part of the EU's energy supply in the future.
Renewable energy makes economic sense
Given today's oil prices, renewables are increasingly seen as an economically sound alternative. With increased deployment of renewable energy sources, the cost of renewable energy can be expected to fall over time, in a pattern similar to that of information technology. Indeed, costs have already fallen significantly in recent years.
Last year, global investment in sustainable energy increased by 43%. Market revenues for solar energy, wind energy, biofuels and fuel cells are forecast to increase to approximately €150 billion by 2016, while record levels of investment in wind, solar and biofuels reflect technological maturity, a growth in policy incentives and increased investor confidence.
Continued and expanded deployment will continue this process. Conversely, the cost of fossil fuels, notably oil, has been steadily increasing since 1998. The dynamics at play are clear: falling renewable energy prices, rising fossil fuel energy prices.
But the use of renewable energy sources also contributes to increasing local and regional employment opportunities. Renewable energy in the EU has a turnover of €30 billion, providing approximately 350,000 jobs. Employment opportunities are vast, ranging from high-tech manufacturing of photovoltaic components to maintenance jobs at wind power plants or in the agricultural sector producing biomass.
The EU's proactive policies on renewable energy provide an industrial opportunity. By beginning the transition to a low-carbon economy earlier than would otherwise be the case, the need for more radical and sudden adjustment is reduced. Money will be saved on imported fossil fuels, and greater diversity of energy sources ensures that the EU is better protected against external shocks.
Renewable energy makes environmental sense
The renewable energy target is closely linked with the EU's greenhouse gas emissions target. Without significantly increasing the share of renewable energy in the EU's energy mix, it will be practically impossible to meet the EU's objectives for reduction of greenhouse gas emissions.
But the term "clean energy" doesn't just apply to reducing greenhouse gas emissions - it also covers traditional pollutants, such as nitrogen oxides, sulphur dioxides and particulates. These are as detrimental to personal health as they are to the environment.
Fossil fuel energy causes environmental impacts all along the chain: from extraction and production to transportation and end use. With renewable energy, these negative effects are minimised, if not removed altogether.
Of course, renewable energy is not always a flawless solution and certain environmental and aesthetic concerns cannot be denied, but new technological solutions will contribute to lessening this impact over time. Looking at the bigger picture, however, there is no doubt that the adverse effects of climate change have far greater significance.
Renewable energy means secure energy supply
Europe's dependence on a limited number of energy sources (oil and gas) is of increasing concern. Oil is no longer a cheap commodity that can be taken for granted. Oil prices fluctuated around $25-$30 during the first years of this decade, but today hover at around $100 per barrel.
From a security of supply perspective, EU renewable energy is mostly generated in the EU. This means that it is less subject to supply disruptions and mitigates fuel price increases. It makes sense, therefore, for the EU to produce more of its own energy, and from a growing variety of renewable energy sources. A diverse supply of energy is a more secure supply of energy.
EU citizens favour renewable energy
Changes in consumer attitudes towards green energy are also becoming increasingly apparent. Surveys show that customers value the environmental benefits of renewable more than conventional polluting energy sources and prefer electricity companies that supply at least part of their power from renewable energy technologies (see information on the Union of Concerned Scientists web site).
According to a Eurobarometer opinion survey undertaken in January 2007, 55% of European citizens perceive great future promise in the use of renewable energies, and 60% think that energy research should be an EU priority.
Moreover, citizens appear to support changing the energy structure, enhancing research and development, and guaranteeing the stability of the energy field. Many of them think that guaranteeing low energy prices and continuous supply of energy should be a priority for national government, and 40% are prepared to pay more for energy from renewable sources.
These sources clearly underline the importance of renewables to Europe's citizens, who consider that increasing renewable energy use is fundamental in order to live in a clean, sustainable and safer environment.
Current status of renewable energy in EU
The European Union is already a world leader in renewable energy, and the sector has huge and growing economic importance worldwide. It is the EU's ambition to stay at the forefront of this fast-developing area. So far, however, development has been uneven across the EU, and renewable energies still represent only a small share of the EU's total energy mix relative to the dominance of gas, oil and coal.
Different renewable energies are at different stages of technological and commercial development. In certain locations and under certain conditions, sources such as wind, hydro, biomass and solar thermal are already economically viable. But others, such as photovoltaic, will depend on increased demand to improve economies of scale and lower costs.
Currently, two EU directives in the field of renewable energy are in force: one for electricity and one for biofuels. The third sector, heating and cooling, has been excluded at the European level so far. The 2020 target setting offers an opportunity to propose one comprehensive directive covering all three sectors of renewable energies.
This makes it possible to put in place both individual measures in the different sectors and to address cross-cutting issues (such as support schemes and administrative barriers). A single directive and single national action plans will encourage member states to think of energy policy in a more integrated way, concentrating on the best allocation of resources.
The EC's proposed new directive sets out renewable energy targets and aims to provide a stable and integrated framework for all renewable energy, which is critical to ensure investors have the confidence needed to make renewables play their envisaged role. At the same time, the framework is sufficiently flexible to take into account the specific situations in member states and to ensure that they have leeway to meet their targets in a cost-effective manner, including through an improved regime for transfers of guarantees of origin.
In addition, the directive contains specific measures to remove barriers to renewable energy's development, such as excessive administrative controls, and to encourage greater use of better-performing types of renewable energy.
Background
In January 2007, the EC put forward an integrated energy and climate change proposal that addressed the issues of energy supply, climate change and industrial development. Two months later, European heads of state endorsed the plan and agreed to an Energy Policy for Europe.
The plan called for:
- 20% increase in energy efficiency.
- 20% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions.
- 20% share of renewables in overall EU energy consumption by 2020.
- 10% biofuel component in vehicle fuel by 2020.
These targets are very ambitious: today 8.5% of EU's energy is renewable. To achieve a 20% share by 2020 will require major efforts across all sectors of the economy and by all member states.
A Europe-wide approach is needed to ensure that the effort for reaching the 20% target is shared equitably between member states. Furthermore, there must be investor certainty regarding the objectives and the pathway to be followed.
Source: European Commission (EC) .